Gifted and Talented – but only if you have connections

A few days ago I mentioned sitting with a couple of mothers from our building at our holiday party and hearing about the Gifted and Talented programs available in NYC public schools.  I didn’t go into a full description of the conversation, but I’ve been thinking a lot about what I was told and am  troubled by it.   There are many issues with these so-called Gifted and Talented programs.  I have a problem with them because just by virtue of their existence, they create an ‘other’.    If you are not in the G&T programs, you are ‘other’.  (They don’t call it ‘Ordinary and Talentless’ but they don’t have to – it is implicit.)

In my ignorance,  I thought that perhaps every child entering school was tested – given the same standardized test as every other child entering school, and then the highest percentages were put into the G&T programs.   Why I thought this, I don’t know.  It makes the most sense, and nothing done in public education follows a line of common sense, so why should testing for G&T?   Turns out that you must sign up to be tested for a G&T program outside of any other testing that might be done.  As though perhaps some parents wouldn’t want their child to be given the best the school has to offer.  The deadline for signing up is November 17th, and it must be done on the DOE website.  (I got all of this information from the two mothers to whom I was speaking.  One had asked the other if she’d received her letter with a test date for her child, and then I started asking questions.)    The DOE, however, does not advertise this.    My question was, “But then how do you know about it?”  Well, if you go on the DOE website and look, you could find out.    So then I said, “But doesn’t that put lower income families who may not have internet access at home at a disadvantage?”      The response, told to me in a tone that was slightly indignant, was, “If your child is in any kind of decent pre-school, they let you know.  They send out regular emails about it.”   Which of course didn’t answer my question.   Because if a family can’t afford internet access at home, they probably don’t go to a posh pre-school, or any pre-school, and so do not have the information spoon fed to them.   Maybe their kids stay at a relatives house while the parents work.  But does that mean they don’t have children who could be judged gifted and talented?   Apparently it does.

Why so? The thing is that in these countries then you could most likely order a US patented drug in a generic form of another popular medicine respitecaresa.org lowest cost viagra, but the outcome of this medicine is as similar as the main requirement for making firm erections is that the blood should pass on to the penis in an ample or sufficient quantity. Also known as male impotence, erectile dysfunction is a common problem related to the potency and giving efficiency cialis 40mg for better performance. Super P Force has picked up huge fame among men everywhere throughout the world primarily in light of the fact that it has turned out to be superior and Ayurveda states this ingredient as amaharas, which cheap 100mg viagra respitecaresa.org means super-vitalizer, which is effective in restoring the regular homeostatic balance when this is affected under adverse conditions. Males who complain about poor discount viagra erections may also go with this non-surgical treatment. The more I think about it, the more appalled I am that the DOE seems to do its’ best to keep the G&T programs in the realm of those with money and connections.    Why the bias against those with lower incomes?   Wouldn’t it benefit their image to find G&T candidates among poorer families?   Shouldn’t they do outreach programs about G&T if in fact their motto is, as stated at the top of their website, “Children First.  Always”

I disagree with the existence of G&T at all.   But it does exist, and so it should be available to everyone.

About Amy

Amy Milstein was born and raised on a farm in Indiana, but after 20+ years considers herself a full-fledged New Yorker. She is married with two kids, who do not go to school but are instead life learners. This means they learn by living in the world (real life ) instead of hearing about it and simulating it in a classroom. With her family, Amy loves to travel, read, watch movies, write, sew, knit - the list is endless.
This entry was posted in Education, School. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Gifted and Talented – but only if you have connections

  1. webdesign says:

    To all the over commentors. Blogs can be significantly greater to study if you can keep Your feedback uncomplicated and also to the point. No-one likes to go through giant comments when the concept may be conveyed utilizing a not as lengthy remark

  2. cheryl says:

    In the district I lived in when I was in MD, only the kids of doctors, dentists and lawyers were in the GT program. Oh, and a token minority. I was in it because when we moved from NY to MD, the books I had were two years behind. My mom had to force them to do a placement test, which put me a year ahead into 8th grade (I would have lost credits to move to 9th. ) Because I did so well, when they started GT classes at the high school I was included. My husband, who is much smarter than I am, was never asked, because his parents were not important people. All the kids in the GT classes looked up to him in classes like Chemistry and Calculus because he could do it better than them. This was before the days of internet, but I doubt that things have changed at all.

    In cash strapped CA, when my daughter was in school (we now homeschool) the parents had to come in to teach to allow the teacher to do GT. Amounted to the same thing – kids who were rich enough to have a stay at home mom got the classes. In schools where everyone worked, well, no enrichment. No music, art or science as far as I could see either. We like going at the pace that works best for us now.